Science Comics : Cats

by Andy Hirsch

Andy Hirsch’s Science Comics: Cats: Nature and Nurture uses a playful comics narrative to explore the science behind domestic cats, their wild relatives, and their relationships with people. Cartoon feline characters, visual explanations, and humor introduce readers to evolution, genetics, anatomy, senses, and behavior. Although its characters and framing are imaginative, the book is best taught as informational science comics rather than conventional picture-book fiction.

Big Idea

Domestic cats’ bodies and behaviors reflect both their evolutionary inheritance and their experiences. Comics can make complex science understandable by carefully pacing information through pictures, dialogue, and visual comparisons.

Discussion Questions

1.Which everyday cat behavior makes more sense to you after reading, and how does the book help explain it?
2.In what ways are house cats similar to their wild relatives, and which differences seem most important?
3.How might both inherited traits and experiences influence the way a cat behaves?
4.Where did a picture explain something more clearly than words alone could? What did the artist help you notice?
5.How does Hirsch make scientific information entertaining, and how can readers distinguish a humorous invention from a scientific claim?

Lesson Plan

⏱ 45 minutes: shared reading and discussion, 10 minutes; planning, 5 minutes; creating, 15 minutes; partner review, 8 minutes; revision and sharing, 7 minutes.📦 Copies of the book or access to a shared copy, paper, pencils, crayons or markers, chart paper, and optional sticky notes and four-panel templates. No live animals are needed.

Learning Goals

Explain one feline trait or behavior using information from the book.
Distinguish fictional dialogue and humorous framing from factual scientific explanation.
Use panel sequence, pictures, and captions to communicate a clear scientific idea.
Revise a comic to change its reading pace without changing its scientific meaning.
Use a relevant detail from the book to support an explanation.

Activity Steps

1.Read and examine a selected sequence about feline senses, anatomy, or hunting behavior. Ask students to identify what the pictures teach and what the words add.
2.Build a class chart with three columns: observable behavior, scientific explanation, and supporting detail from the book. Let each student choose one example.
3.Fold paper into four panels. Plan a sequence: notice, prepare, act, explain. Discuss which moment should feel slow and which should feel fast.
4.Create the comic using drawings, brief dialogue, and at least one factual caption. For K–1, offer a cat outline, picture choices, and dictated captions; for grades 2–5, require an independently written explanation.
5.Exchange comics with a partner. Partners identify the fastest moment, the slowest moment, and the scientific fact they learned, then check that fact against the selected reading.
6.Revise one pacing choice and share. Explain how a larger image, fewer words, an added pause, or a clearer caption improved the reader’s experience.

Standards Connections

ELA: CCSS RI.K.7, RI.1.7, and RI.3.7 — Connect illustrations to information and explain how images contribute to understanding a text; select the standard appropriate to the class.
ELA: CCSS W.K.2, W.2.2, and W.5.2 — Use drawing, dictation, or informative writing to explain a topic with relevant information.
ELA: CCSS SL.K.1–SL.5.1 — Participate in collaborative conversations, listen to others, and build on shared ideas.
Science: NGSS 1-LS1-1 — Support learning about how external animal parts help animals survive and meet their needs; the comic is a supporting task, not a complete engineering assessment.
Science: NGSS 3-LS3-1 and 3-LS3-2 — Connect discussion of inherited feline traits and environmental influences to grade-three heredity learning; additional observations and evidence are needed for full performance expectations.

Pace-Write-Read Study with Pace-Write It!

In Science Comics: Cats, Andy Hirsch makes the reader move between two kinds of attention: enjoying an animated feline narrative and examining scientific explanations. Small action beats can carry readers quickly through a sequence, while diagrams, labels, comparisons, and denser explanations invite them to slow down. A Pace-Write-Read study asks students to notice those changes and consider why a writer-artist would want a reader to linger in one place but hurry through another. Teach the book as a mentor text for explanatory writing as well as visual storytelling. Read a manageable excerpt aloud, reread its pictures, and ask students to trace how the sequence turns a familiar cat behavior into a scientific question. Younger students can act out the sequence and dictate captions; older students can analyze how panel size, vocabulary, dialogue, and factual captions distribute information. The goal is not simply to write less or read faster: it is to give each idea the time and space a reader needs.

Element	How to notice or teach it in the novel
1. Pacing	Compare a feline action sequence with a science-heavy explanation. Have students identify where they read quickly, where they slowed down, and which visual or verbal choices caused the change.
2. Plot	Trace the events in a selected narrative passage separately from the scientific ideas it introduces. Discuss how the cats’ actions give readers reasons to learn about feline biology rather than encountering an unrelated list of facts.
3. Prosody	Read a cat’s dialogue expressively, then read an explanatory caption with clear emphasis on key information. Discuss how oral phrasing can help listeners distinguish a joke, a reaction, and an explanation.
4. Word	Select a scientific term from the reading and locate the picture or surrounding words that help explain it. Ask students to pair one precise term with a child-friendly explanation in their own comics.
5. Concept	Use the subtitle Nature and Nurture to frame a discussion of inheritance and experience. Help students avoid treating every cat behavior as entirely inherited or entirely learned.
6. Voice & Worldview	Notice how the playful feline framing makes cats interesting subjects of scientific investigation. Discuss how humor can encourage curiosity without making a character’s opinion into scientific evidence.
7. Point of View	Contrast a cat-centered reaction with a human scientific explanation of that same behavior. Students can write one speech balloon from the cat’s perspective and one factual caption from an observer’s perspective.
8. Setting & Place	Examine how domestic environments and references to wild habitats shape readers’ understanding of cats. Ask which environmental details help explain an animal’s needs or behavior.
9. Original Characters	Study how Hirsch gives cartoon cats expressive faces and recognizable attitudes while retaining feline features. Have students invent a cat guide whose personality supports, rather than distracts from, an accurate explanation.
10. Dialogue	Identify a speech balloon that contributes a reaction, joke, or explanation. Try removing it and ask whether the sequence loses information, personality, or momentum.
11. Details	Look closely at ears, eyes, paws, tails, and body positions in the selected illustrations. Ask which details communicate scientific information and which primarily communicate emotion.
12. Descriptions	Compare a written explanation of a feline feature with its visual representation. Students should describe a feature by connecting its appearance or structure to what it helps a cat do.
13. Firsts	Find the first introduction of an unfamiliar scientific idea in your excerpt. Notice whether Hirsch prepares readers with a familiar cat action, a question, an image, or a definition before adding complexity.
14. Immediacy & Engagement	Examine how expressive cats and recognizable behaviors invite readers into the science. Ask students to begin their comics with an observable action rather than a long opening definition.
15. Story Scenes, Summaries & Structures	Distinguish a moment shown panel by panel from a passage that summarizes a broader scientific process. Discuss why a pounce can be dramatized moment by moment while evolutionary change needs a different scale.
16. Tension / Suspense / Surprise	Look for a setup that makes readers anticipate a cat’s next action or reaction. Students can create a brief pause before a pounce, then use the outcome to introduce the explanation.
17. Flashback, Flash-Forward, Cliffhanger	When the book moves from present-day cats to evolutionary or domestication history, identify the signals that mark the time shift. Distinguish scientific background from a character’s remembered flashback, and treat cliffhangers as an optional technique to test rather than an assumed feature.
18. Page Turns and Chapter Breaks	Examine what information appears just before and after a page turn or section boundary. Ask whether the break completes an explanation, introduces a new question, or gives readers a useful stopping point.
19. Pace & Creativity	Have students redraw the same cat action in two panels and then four. Compare how added stages can create anticipation or clarify movement without adding new scientific content.
20. Play	Use the book’s playful cartoon treatment as permission to experiment with expressive poses and imaginative dialogue. Keep the scientific caption accurate even when the cat’s commentary is fanciful.
21. Performance	Assign readers to voice the cats and a separate reader to deliver factual captions from a selected excerpt. Pause between panels so students experience how performance can reveal the sequence’s timing.
22. Personality	Notice how posture, facial expression, and wording give feline characters personality. Discuss why a cartoon cat’s attitude should not be treated as evidence that every real cat behaves the same way.
23. Humor	Find a moment where a cartoon reaction or playful contrast makes the science memorable. Ask students to explain both the joke and the scientific idea so the humor does not replace understanding.
24. Pause	Invite students to linger over a labeled illustration rather than immediately continuing to the next panel. In their own comics, they can create a pause with a still pose or a larger explanatory image.
25. Poetry / Poetic Devices	Although the book is not poetry, inspect the excerpt for sound play, vivid comparisons, or patterned language. If none appears, students can try an original alliterative phrase about a cat and test whether it clarifies or distracts.
26. Repetition	Track a repeated scientific term or recurring visual feature across the excerpt. Discuss how repetition can reinforce understanding while a changed image adds new information.
27. Rhythm	Follow the sequence of speech balloons, captions, and images with a finger to feel the reading rhythm. Compare a run of short exchanges with a panel that requires sustained observation.
28. Punctuation	Examine punctuation in the selected dialogue and read it aloud accordingly. Students can compare a question mark, period, and exclamation point in the same invented cat line to hear how emphasis changes.
29. Questions	Turn a familiar behavior from the book into an inquiry, such as asking how a cat’s senses help it locate prey. Trace which words and pictures provide an answer and which questions require further research.
30. Compare-Contrast	Use the book’s treatment of domestic cats and wild relatives to compare a shared feature and a meaningful difference. Keep comparisons specific rather than describing house cats as simply miniature versions of every big cat.
31. Objects	Examine how an object near a cat can make behavior visible—for example, something the cat watches, investigates, or pursues. Students can include a paper ball in their comic to establish the target of a pretend hunt.
32. Threes	Test a three-beat adaptation of a feline action: notice, crouch, pounce. Treat this as a student composition experiment, not a claim that Hirsch consistently uses a rule of three.
33. Lists	Extract a short list of related facts from the reading, such as features involved in sensing or movement. Compare presenting those facts together with distributing them across panels, noting the effect on reading pace.
34. White Space & Negative Space	Inspect the space between panels and around figures, labels, and balloons. Ask how uncluttered areas help readers follow a cat’s movement or focus on a scientific feature.
35. Art & Graphics	Study how explanatory graphics and cartoon scenes perform different teaching jobs. Have students identify something learned from a label, comparison, or anatomical image that dialogue alone would not communicate as efficiently.
36. Interactives & Gamification	Turn a selected illustration into a teacher-created observation challenge: identify a feature, describe what it does, and support the answer with the reading. Make clear that this game is a classroom extension, not necessarily a built-in feature of the book.
37. Placement	Trace the intended reading order of panels, balloons, and captions in an actual spread. Students should position their own words so readers encounter the action and explanation in a purposeful order.
38. Form	Discuss why informational comics suit a subject involving bodies, movement, and comparisons across animals. Rewrite one short sequence as prose and compare what becomes easier or harder to communicate.
39. Dummy	Create a rough paper mock-up before producing finished art. Students can move the pounce or the scientific explanation to another panel or page and test how that change affects anticipation and clarity.
40. Passion	Ask which surprising feline fact makes students want to observe or learn more about cats. Use that curiosity to choose a writing topic while emphasizing respectful observation and never provoking an animal for a reaction.

Pace-Write It!

PART 2 QUICK TASK — One Pounce, Two Speeds (20 minutes) Minutes 0–4 — READ: Revisit a short sequence explaining feline hunting behavior, senses, or movement. Identify one supported fact and distinguish it from the cartoon framing. Minutes 4–7 — PACE: Fold a sheet into four panels. Plan a cat noticing a paper ball, crouching, pouncing, and pausing afterward; decide how to make the preparation feel slow and the leap feel quick. Minutes 7–14 — WRITE: Draw the sequence. Use two preparatory panels, one uncluttered action panel with little text, and one explanation panel with a factual caption grounded in the reading. K–1 students may dictate the caption; grades 2–5 should name the relevant feature or behavior and explain its role. Minutes 14–18 — READ AGAIN: Partners read the comics and identify where they slowed down, where they sped up, and what science they learned. Check the explanation against the book and revise one confusing or inaccurate detail. Minutes 18–20 — REFLECT: Each student completes: ‘I slowed the reader down by ___. I sped the reader up by ___. My scientific explanation shows ___.’ Keep the demonstration entirely on paper; do not ask students to test hunting responses with live cats.

Classroom Activities

From Couch to Pounce

Students create a four-panel science comic that transforms an ordinary house-cat moment into an explanation of feline biology. A cat notices a pretend prey object, prepares to pounce, acts, and then helps readers understand the behavior through an accurate caption. Students experiment with making the action quick while giving the scientific explanation room to breathe.

Create a free account to reveal this guide

Your free account includes one complete guide download — the full teacher’s guide, discussion questions, classroom activities, and the Pace-Write-Read writing workshop.

Create Free Account Sign in

Discussion questions PWR workshop PDF download